Surprise and Delight: Why Unexpected Appreciation Often Creates the Strongest Loyalty
.jpeg)
Research suggests that unexpected acts of appreciation can generate stronger emotional connections with employees and customers than even the most carefully designed rewards programs when they are timely, authentic, and personalized.
By Bruce Bolger
Why Unexpected Appreciation Works
The Ritz-Carlton Lesson
Surprise and Delight for Employees
Surprise and Delight for Customers
Building a Culture of Appreciation
Click here to subscribe to RRN weekly, and here for an RRN media kit.
Organizations spend billions of dollars annually on employee recognition, incentives, loyalty programs, and customer experience initiatives. Yet many overlook one of the most powerful—and often least expensive—tools available: surprise and delight.
Whether directed toward employees or customers, unexpected gestures of appreciation create memorable experiences that strengthen emotional connections, reinforce desired behaviors, and inspire advocacy. While structured rewards and recognition programs remain essential, experts increasingly recognize that some of the most impactful moments occur when appreciation arrives unexpectedly.
The concept is grounded in psychology. Nobel Prize-winning psychologist and behavioral economist Daniel Kahneman found that people often judge experiences based on their emotional peaks and endings rather than on the average of every interaction. A positive surprise can therefore have an outsized impact on how people remember an organization and whether they choose to continue doing business with it.
At the same time, workplace appreciation expert Dr. Paul White, coauthor of The 5 Languages of Appreciation in the Workplace, has found that people respond most strongly to appreciation that is personalized and meaningful rather than generic. His research suggests that employees are more likely to feel valued when appreciation reflects their individual preferences and contributions rather than a standardized recognition process.
Traditional rewards programs generally operate on predictable rules. Employees expect service awards. Salespeople expect incentives for achieving goals. Customers expect loyalty points for purchases. These programs play an important role in reinforcing desired behaviors, but their impact can diminish over time because they become expected.
Unexpected recognition activates a different emotional response. Behavioral researchers have found that surprises attract attention, heighten positive emotions, and create stronger memories. In effect, surprise can amplify the perceived value of an experience without necessarily increasing its cost.
This is particularly important at a time when organizations continue to struggle with employee engagement, customer loyalty, and trust. Many companies focus heavily on compensation and benefits while overlooking the human desire to feel genuinely appreciated.
One of the most famous examples of surprise and delight comes from the luxury hospitality industry. For years, the Ritz-Carlton became known for empowering frontline employees to create memorable guest experiences without seeking managerial approval for every decision. Stories abound of employees replacing lost items, arranging personalized experiences, or solving customer problems in ways that exceeded expectations. The company's long-publicized practice of giving employees significant discretion to resolve guest issues became a symbol of trust in frontline judgment.
The broader lesson is not about spending money. It is about empowering people closest to customers to make decisions that demonstrate appreciation when opportunities arise. Organizations often spend months designing loyalty programs while requiring employees to obtain multiple approvals before doing something meaningful for a customer. Ritz-Carlton demonstrated that giving employees latitude can often produce greater loyalty than any formal program alone.
Many organizations assume appreciation means rewards. In reality, appreciation often means demonstrating that someone is seen, understood, and valued. For employees, surprise and delight can take many forms:
-
A CEO unexpectedly calling an employee to thank them for solving a difficult customer issue.
-
Providing an extra day off following the successful completion of a major project.
-
Sending a personalized gift related to an employee's interests.
-
Recognizing behind-the-scenes contributors who rarely receive public acknowledgment.
-
Inviting family members to participate in milestone celebrations.
-
Providing an unexpected professional development opportunity aligned with career aspirations.
The most effective gestures are not necessarily the most expensive. According to Dr. White's research, appreciation is most meaningful when it aligns with what the recipient values. For some employees, public recognition may be motivating. Others may prefer personal conversations, quality time with leaders, opportunities for growth, or acts of support. This personalization is what transforms a reward into a memorable expression of appreciation.
The same principle applies to customer relationships. Most loyalty programs reward transactions. Surprise and delight rewards relationships.
-
A casino might unexpectedly upgrade a loyal guest's room, provide complimentary show tickets, or invite a customer to an exclusive event.
-
A restaurant could surprise a regular patron with a chef's tasting, complimentary dessert, or a personal note from management.
-
A wireless carrier might proactively waive a fee following a service disruption or provide an unexpected loyalty benefit to a long-term customer.
-
A retailer could send a personalized thank-you gift recognizing years of patronage.
-
A hotel might remember a guest's preferences and ensure their favorite amenities are waiting upon arrival.
These actions create stories that customers often share with friends, family, and colleagues. In many cases, the resulting goodwill far exceeds the cost of the gesture.
Organizations seeking to incorporate surprise and delight into their culture should avoid turning it into a rigid process. By definition, surprise loses impact when it becomes predictable. Instead, organizations can establishprinciples and provide employees with the flexibility to act.
Successful programs typically share several characteristics. They:
-
Gather information about employee and customer preferences.
-
Empower managers and frontline employees to make decisions.
-
Establish budgets and guidelines without creating excessive bureaucracy.
-
Focus on personalization rather than monetary value.
-
Recognize behaviors and contributions soon after they occur.
-
View appreciation as a leadership responsibility rather than solely an HR or customer service function.
Importantly, surprise and delight should complement—not replace—formal recognition, incentive, and loyalty programs. Structured programs provide consistency and fairness. Surprise and delight provides emotional impact.
For employees, surprise and delight communicates, "You matter." For customers, it communicates, "You are more than a transaction." In a world increasingly defined by automation and standardization, those messages may be among the most valuable rewards an organization can offer.
And, yes, the long-term impact can be measured through customer relationship or human resources management software in terms of retention, referrals, or other engagements.
Enterprise Engagement Alliance Services 
Celebrating our 17h year, the Enterprise Engagement Alliance helps organizations enhance performance through:
1. Information and marketing opportunities on stakeholder management and total rewards:
ESM Weekly on stakeholder management since 2009; click here for a media kit.
RRN Weekly on total rewards since 1996; click here for a EEA YouTube channel on enterprise engagement, human capital, and total rewards insights and how-to information since 2020.
2. Learning: Purpose Leadership and Stakeholder
Management Academy to enhance future equity value and performance for your organization.
3. Books on implementation: Enterprise Engagement for CEOs and Enterprise Engagement: The Roadmap.
4. Advisory services and research: Strategic guidance, learning and certification on stakeholder management, measurement, metrics, and corporate sustainability reporting.
5. Permission-based targeted business development to identify and build relationships with the people most likely to buy.
6. Public speaking and meeting facilitation on stakeholder management. The world’s leading speakers on all aspects of stakeholder management across the enterprise.
